Sibley Insurance Group
How we got $2.4M
Based on typical figures for its industry (2022 Economic Census), not its own records.
What we know
Signs of a sale Unlikely to sell soon
- Family in the business (Steven Sibley, Licensed Producer/Broker)
From public records and the company's website, not a statement that it's for sale.
What they do
Sibley Insurance Group is an independent licensed insurance producer that works for its clients, focusing on educating them about Medicare and health insurance options without high-pressure sales.
From the company's website. Industry: Insurance agencies.
Compared with similar businesses nearby
| Business | Est. revenue | Distance |
|---|---|---|
| Sibley Insurance Group this business | $1.6M | — |
| Tassiello Insurance Agency Oklahoma City | $806K | 0.0 mi |
| Irving Tovar Farmers Insurance Agency Oklahoma City | $806K | 0.0 mi |
| DMT Financial Group Oklahoma City | $806K | 0.0 mi |
| Sharpe Insurance Solutions Oklahoma City | $806K | 0.0 mi |
| INES BELMAN Oklahoma City · 2 employees | $547K | 0.1 mi |
| State Auto Insurance Agency Oklahoma City | $1.6M | 0.4 mi |
The full calculation
Figures are shown toward the upper part of their range rather than at its middle.
Brought up to date assuming revenue has grown 8% a year since 2020, when the PPP figures were reported; included above.
| Estimated value = EBITDA × typical sale multiple | $2.4M |
| Multiple for this size and industry | 4.5× |
| Value range | $876K – $3.6M |
This business has no PPP loan on record, so there is no business-specific data. The figures are the typical estimated revenue of Agencies, brokerages, and other insurance related activities businesses in our Oklahoma data: the middle value, with the range covering the middle half of those businesses. EBITDA applies the industry margin (33%). Treat these as a rough guide.
| Revenue range | $742K – $2.0M |
| EBITDA range | $243K – $660K |
| Industry (NAICS) | Agencies, brokerages, and other insurance related activities (5242) |
EBITDA margin: from IRS tax returns of S corporations in this industry (2019–2022), adjusted for company size: smaller companies typically run higher margins. EBITDA here is after owners' salaries.
Benchmarks: US Economic Census 2022, OK. These are statistical estimates, not reported financials. Listing details come from Overture Maps open data. Full methodology
People & advisors
“Our team is made up of independent licensed insurance producers, founded by husband and wife, Christina and Steven.”
Leadership
- SSSteven SibleyLicensed Producer/Broker · Company website · source
- RSRachel SibleyLicensed producer/broker · Company website · source
- MHMelissa HighLicensed producer/broker Medicare Products · Company website · source
- BBBraden BusseyLicensed producer/broker, Proud Veteran · Company website · source
- JOJonathan ObergLicensed producer/broker · Company website · source
From the company's own website and public filings (DOL Form 5500, IRS Form 990, SBA). Roles are as stated there and may be out of date.
2 locations
| 5350 S Western Ave Ste 540 | Oklahoma City | This listing |
| 201 W Oklahoma Ave Ste 230 | Guthrie | View |
Revenue, profit and value are for the whole company.
Public records
Matched to this business by name and address from public government data; a match can occasionally be wrong.
About Sibley Insurance Group
Sibley Insurance Group is an insurance agencies company in Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, in business since 2017. It is owned by Christina Sibley (Founder). Its estimated annual revenue is about $1.6M, with roughly $528K of EBITDA. Its estimated business value is $2.4M (likely range $876K–$3.6M). It has 2 locations.
Common questions
- Who owns Sibley Insurance Group?
- Sibley Insurance Group is owned by Christina Sibley (Founder), according to public sources such as the company's website or filings.
- How much revenue does Sibley Insurance Group make?
- SeeBITDA estimates Sibley Insurance Group's annual revenue at about $1.6M (likely between $742K and $2.0M), based on public records such as its PPP loan and retirement-plan filings, brought up to 2026.
- What is Sibley Insurance Group worth?
- About $2.4M, roughly 4.5× its estimated EBITDA of $528K, typical for a insurance agencies company its size. Likely range: $876K–$3.6M.
- When was Sibley Insurance Group founded?
- Sibley Insurance Group has been in business since 2017.